What others see as messes, some see opportunities | David Agnew

Loading player...
Don't be afraid to try something new.

What does it take to lead in systems that are complex, constrained, and constantly changing?

Daniel Atlin sits down with David Agnew, President of Seneca Polytechnic, whose career has spanned politics, finance, international development, and higher education. One common is stepping into organisations at moments of tension, transition, and uncertainty.

This conversation explores what leadership really looks like in public institutions, where the stakes are high, the problems are rarely neat, and the pressure to act is constant. It’s about navigating competing demands, making decisions you know will be unpopular, and holding steady in the storm.

Key insights:
1. Leadership is holding tension, not resolving it. Organisations want stability but reality demands change.
2. Not all “mess” is the same. It can be a transition, a leadership gap, or a system under pressure
3. Public institutions operate under different rules. Unlike businesses, they don’t choose their customers and can’t walk away from problems
4. Leadership is not a popularity contest. Leaders must make decisions without full agreement, withstand criticism, and accept not everyone will be satisfied
5. Inner sensemaking shapes outer action. Before decisions there is a process happening internally: What matters? What do I stand for? What am I willing to act on?
6. Time horizons matter. In many public systems today's decisions may not yield results for years. Leaders must think long-term but act in the present, and manage expectations in between
7. Careers and leadership journeys are rarely linear. Plans change, opportunities emerge, and growth often comes from stepping into the unknown

This episode is a reminder that leadership in messy systems isn’t about having the answers. What some people see as a mess, others see as meaningful work.
Chapters
  • 00:00 Introduction and career overview
  • 02:01 Early government experience and economic crisis
  • 06:07 Lessons from government and long-term planning
  • 13:07 Public sector challenges and anti-tax mentality
  • 19:01 COVID-19 vaccine mandate decisions
  • 21:03 Political experience and thick skin
  • 26:13 UNICEF and international development
  • 32:19 Historical moments and individual impact
  • 36:44 Polytechnic education and Canadian higher education
  • 41:43 System collaboration and funding challenges
  • 45:03 Recent funding and future challenges
  • 48:46 AI impact and future of higher education
  • 51:50 Career advice and networking
  • 55:08 Final reflections on career flexibility
15 Apr English Canada Management · Society & Culture

Other recent episodes

Putting the Mouth Back into the Body Politic | Sara Hurley

Public Service = Designing Fairness at Scale. In this episode of Messy, Daniel Atlin is joined by Sara Hurley, former Chief Dental Officer for England, a leader whose career spans frontline clinical care, military service, and senior government leadership. Few have operated as consistently at the intersection of individual care,…
25 Mar 56 min

Is the University Model Broken? | Tim Blackman

Rethinking higher education — and finding your purpose. What if the real problem with higher education isn’t funding, technology, or rankings, but the model itself? In this episode, Daniel Atlin speaks with Tim Blackman, former Vice-Chancellor and President of the Open University, about whether the dominant university model is simply…
11 Mar 51 min

Making Sense of Making Sense | Why the mess matters

This episode is different. There’s no guest. It’s just me, Daniel Atlin, answering the question I ask every leader who comes on Messy: to riff off the Kierkegaard quote “Life must be lived forwards, but can only be understood backwards." I look back at the moments that shaped my curiosity…
4 Mar 8 min

Should you Collaborate with the Enemy? | Adam Kahane

If you're not part of the problem, you can't be part of the solution. In this episode of Messy, Daniel Atlin sits down with global facilitator and systems practitioner Adam Kahane to explore what it really means to collaborate when agreement feels impossible. They explore collaboration across deep divides, the…
25 Feb 51 min

Between the Dance Floor and the Balcony | Iain Martin

Leading across Australia, the UK, and New Zealand. What does it mean to lead a university when trust in public institutions is eroding and the rules keep changing? In this episode of Messy, I speak with Iain Martin, President and Vice-Chancellor of Deakin University, about navigating leadership in the thick…
9 Feb 57 min