Big Name Funds Underperform. What are you paying for?

Loading player...
Get my book here: https://www.moneywithcarla.com/book

Free Investment Masterclass: https://learn.moneywithcarla.com/masterclass2026

Most South Africans are losing hundreds of thousands of rands in household-name investment funds, without even realising it. In this video I compare real fund performance from two of my students against equivalent ETFs, and show you exactly how to benchmark any active fund yourself (it takes about five minutes).

What you'll learn:
1. Why big brand = good investment is one of the most expensive assumptions you can make
2. How to find a fund's minimum disclosure document and read the numbers that matter
3. A simple method to compare any active fund against its benchmark index
What 95% of SA equity funds and 100% of global equity funds have in common (spoiler: it's not good)
4. The real rand difference between 1% and 6% annual underperformance over 20 years
Chapters
  • 00:00 The expensive assumption most investors make
  • 00:47 The two real examples we're looking at
  • 01:25 How to find a fund's minimum disclosure document
  • 01:47 Comparing a South African equity fund to the Satrix Top 40
  • 02:28 Fees on top of underperformance – the double hit
  • 02:56 SPIVA scorecard: how active funds really perform over 10 years
  • 03:22 The global equity fund comparison
  • 04:21 What the rand difference actually looks like over 20 years
  • 05:15 What to do if you're already in the wrong fund 5:54 Adrian's story: how he fixed it
20 Sep English South Africa Investing

Other recent episodes

Top Divorce Lawyer: What Everyone Should Know

What does divorce actually cost, and what should you know before your marriage ends? In this episode, I sit down with a Cape Town-based divorce lawyer who has worked on thousands of divorce cases to unpack the legal, financial and emotional realities of divorce. We cover the cost of divorce,…
12 Nov 1 hr 02 min

What happens when two financial experts sit down?

What happens when two financial experts sit down to talk money and don't see eye to eye?I sat down with fellow financial expert Munya, also known as Modern Money, to discuss investing, retirement annuities, local vs offshore markets, ETFs, investment fees and building wealth. We share different perspectives, challenge each…
1 Nov 2027 1 hr 03 min

Where My Money Actually Goes

Ever wondered how I invest my own money? In this episode, I’m sharing the ETFs I hold, what I pay in fees and how I decide where my money goes first. I’ll also walk you through my cash flow waterfall and how I prioritise everything from paying off expensive debt…
25 Oct 10 min

How a 2.75% Fee Could Halve Your Retirement

Market crashes might grab the headlines, but investment fees could be quietly costing you millions. In this episode, discover how a 2.75% annual fee can significantly reduce your retirement savings, why two investors with the same income and contributions can end up millions apart, and how to check what you're…
18 Oct 10 min

Buying or Renting in 2027? (The 7% Rule)

Join my masterclass: learn.moneywithcarla.com/invest Is it actually better to buy property or rent and invest the difference? I ran the numbers so you don't have to. Again. In this video I break down the buy vs rent debate properly, including the 7% rule, real property growth rates, and how stock…
13 Oct 12 min